The Cover Letter Conundrum: Are They Still in the Game?

Posted by

In the fast-paced world of recruitment, where emojis sometimes replace words and TikToks are playing a role in the job process, one traditional relic seems to be under the microscope—the cover letter. 

So, let's embark on a whimsical yet informative journey to answer the burning question: Are cover letters still a thing, or are they about as useful as a fax machine at a coding boot camp? 

Cover Letters: The Supporters

Picture this: You're sifting through a pile of resumes as high as Mt. Everest, and suddenly, you stumble upon a cover letter that's as captivating as a blockbuster movie trailer. It’s witty, it's well-written, and it even throws in a pun about your company's logo. 

Supporters argue that cover letters can be a window into a candidate's soul (or at least their professional soul). They say:

1. Personality Shine: A cover letter is a canvas where candidates can splash their personality. It's like a mini-interview but in writing. 

2. Motivation Matters: Cover letters reveal why a candidate wants the job. Is it for the paycheck, or do they genuinely love crafting code like it's art? 

3. Storytelling Skills: A well-crafted cover letter can narrate a candidate's career story, making it a page-turner for hiring managers. 

Cover Letters: The Critics

Now, imagine you’re on a tight schedule, and you have a pile of resumes to go through faster than a rocket to Mars. Suddenly, you're handed a cover letter that resembles a novel--verbose, lengthy, and almost as exciting as watching paint dry. 

Critics argue that cover letters often feel like reading the fine print of a software license agreement. They say:

1. Redundancy Alert: Sometimes, cover letters parrot what's already in the resume. Is it really necessary to read the same thing twice? 

2. Time Crunch: In today's warp-speed job market, who has the time to read War and Peace-length cover letters for every applicant? 

3. Digital Era: We live in the age of LinkedIn profiles and online portfolios. Isn't a well-constructed digital footprint enough to gauge a candidate's suitability? 

Finding Middle Ground

So, what's the verdict? Are cover letters destined to join the ranks of typewriters and fax machines in the museum of outdated office relics? 

Not necessarily. The key is balance. A cover letter can be a likable sidekick to a resume, not its verbose twin. A concise, engaging cover letter can provide insights into a candidate's personality and motivation.

Employers Should Consider

1. Tailored Approach: Encourage candidates to craft cover letters with a personal touch, showcasing why they're excited about your company specifically. 

2. Efficiency Hacks: Implement efficient methods to review cover letters, such as setting criteria or using applicant tracking systems. Efficiency and fun can coexist! 

3. Cultural Fit: Reflect on your company's culture. If it values personalized communication, a cover letter might be right up your alley. 

The cover letter debate is like a good plot twist in a movie, it keeps us guessing. While it might not be the star of the show, it can add depth and intrigue to the candidate selection process.

So, dear employers, the choice is yours. Just remember, whether you're Team Cover Letter or Team Resume, the goal is to find that shining star who'll make your team soar. 


Become a member to take advantage of more features, like commenting and voting.

Jobs to Watch