So tell me about yourself. - STOP! It's A Trick Question!

Posted by


That’s a trick question! After reading this the 'Hiring Powers That Be' are going to revoke my membership and then cut me off from ever working in the Human Resources field again. OK that may be a bit dramatic but I am revealing one of a hiring manager’s secret weapons. The first question an interviewer most likely asks is "So tell me about yourself." It may sound harmless but watch out, this is where it can get you in deep trouble and cost you the job! Yes, before you have even discussed qualifications and background experience your answer to this question will either keep you in the running or boot you out before the interview is over. The question is designed to be a warm up. When you first greet someone for an interview they would like to get to know you, most likely so you'll warm up, feel more comfortable and at ease talking to them. But be careful because this question often entices people to share personal information. When I say personal information I’m not referring to your social security number and place of birth. I'm referring to you, what you do, who you are, where you go, your family, etc. When I have asked this question in interviews (Yes, I am guilty of being one of those people) I am surprised at the responses that I get. They are hardly ever professional and career focused. Normally a candidate will start off with well I was born in New York City in '74 went to school at Green Park Elementary, had two dogs, I love to play basketball and now I'm married and have two kids. Wrong answer. Sneaky recruiters will use this information against you. They know they can't come out and ask you about your age, religion, marital status, etc. And this is exceptionally tricky for STAY AT HOME MOMS!!! I warn you! USE DISCRETION. I once had an interviewer start of with the ‘So tell me’ question. Knowing what I know, I kept it strictly professional. I said I graduated from XYZ University with a Bachelors of Science in Communications and started my career in Recruiting with a National Staffing Agency, I progressed through the ranks, then moved on to a better opportunity with ABC Corp. I have been with them 6 years and am now seeking a more challenging role as the Human Resources Manager for LMN Inc. See how I kept it purely about my career progression? This is the proper way to answer the question. But the interviewer was not satisfied that I didn't come out and tell him about my personal life and later on in the interview he just came out and asked the illegal personal question. "I am sure you have a family and children don't you? Tell me about that." WHOA! Hello illegal question. I said, you'll have to pardon my response if it comes off negatively but actually I think you really need someone in this Human Resources position that is knowledgeable about current employment law because that is an illegal question and could really get you into a lot of trouble if you ask the wrong person. Thankfully he laughed it off and said "Oh, I didn't know that - it's a good thing you said something. We really do need someone that knows that information." The next day I had an offer on the table. And he never interviewed anyone again - phew, lawsuit averted. The reason why I mentioned previously this question is tricky for stay at home moms is because you get caught in the trap. When they say, so tell me about yourself you immediately want to say "Well, I have two kids and for the last 4 years I have been staying at home taking care of them." I hate to even say this but some employers will look down on this. They'll think oh she has kids and that may detract from her job duties and what about absences if her kids get sick? How much work will she have to miss? I am not saying every employer is like this by any means but there are some out there. Know what your rights are and what is and isn't OK for an interviewer to ask. And if someone says to you in an interview "So tell me about yourself" keep it professional and about your education and experience. Refrain from telling them your whole life story. Hopefully, this will help many of you make it to that next step in the interview process and one step closer to the job of your dreams.
Comment

Become a member to take advantage of more features, like commenting and voting.

  • Diana Leigh
    Diana Leigh
    I was recently asked at an interview to describe my day and what I did when I got home. Weird questions not ones I really felt were appropriate.
  • charles chrismon
    charles chrismon
    I understand the concept of this article because I used to do the same thing. When I was asked "Tell me a little about yourself" I would start rattling off everything I could to attempt to create a personal relationship with the interviewer. I found that giving too much information was slitting my own throat even though I was only attempting to befriend the interviewer in order to better my chances to "fit" and get the job. Thank you for confirming what I found out the hard way.
  • Jim
    Jim
    Actually none of this makes any difference in the world today. All the Human Resources person is looking for is a YOUNG, WARM, BODY, which can be acquired for the least amount of money, looks like it is trainable, and looks and sounds like they will stick with the company through thick and thin and exist on the "small" salary offered.
  • Janice
    Janice
    Another take on this question is: Tell me about your worse boss and your worse boss. Keep the answer completely professional. I didn't because I knew the interviewer from a previous job, felt comfortable sharing and lost the job I was applying for. So whether you know the interviewer from a previous job or not, always praise your previous boss. Mention the bad or good boss each had different management styles that you were able to adapt to. period. I wish I'd have given that answer instead of the answers I gave!
  • Christopher
    Christopher
    Interesting thread, but how far can it go? For instance, should candidates remove their wedding rings before interviews? One way or another, we reveal personal information every time we interact with other people.
  • Lucia
    Lucia
    Once I have been asked by a potential employer "if I have any work restrictions in USA?". I said no, then she asked for "a legal answer, like are you over 18, that type of thing?". I said "yes, I am over 18", then she said "I need a legal answer" to which I responded "yes, I am legally in US, I am a citizen, why? you wonder about my accent?" I never heard from her again, other than a "thank you email" a few days later. Anyone has any idea...was this a legal question?
  • Marinella
    Marinella
    That was great and very helpful.I have another questionwhat you do when your ex employer gives you bad reference, (even worst - not eligible for rehire) just because you were injured on that job, got disabled for few months and he didn't like that. Just using the chance for revenge?do I have any legal rights? is there any law that can protect me?
  • Gina
    Gina
    Thank you so much for sharing.  I never knew how to answer that question but now I do.  It's so tough out there right now so it's nice to have little advantage when you walk into an interview.  
  • Sue
    Sue
    As a Human Resource Manager for over 10 years, I would look at this situation in a completely different light.  I would never think of asking such broad questions for fear of the personal information that may be offered.  If I ask this question and someone tells me they are a disabled, minority, war veteran with 18 children and I don't hire them, they could easily make a cry of discrimination.  There are people who actually do this "for a living".  I don't ever want to invite this type of information sharing.  If someone does manage to sneak in some personal information during the interview, I immediately stop them and inform them that this type of information is not needed and will not be used as part of the hiring decision.  I would strongly discourage anyone from asking this question to potential candidates.  You may get far more than you bargained for.
  • Ravi kishore
    Ravi kishore
    Thank you very much for your valuable information, and i will pass it on.
  • Ian Durgadeen
    Ian Durgadeen
    Thank you, That is helpfulI've gotten caught in that trap before
  • Peak Recruiters
    Peak Recruiters
    Thanks for sharing your thoughts and expertise on this subject. This is a tricky question and certainly one you want to answer properly.
  • SUNDAY SEDRACK
    SUNDAY SEDRACK
    I appreciate your knowledge and sharing, i've learned a lot from you because, whenever i met that question, i would right away go to my personel life style and tend to go away my profession. thanks a lot. Sedrack
  • Karen Fitts
    Karen Fitts
    I am truly glad to have read this post.  I have been asked this question many times and have provided the "professional" response.  I have also been asked directly, "How old are your children?" without me indicating that I have children.  This question was asked to obtain an approximate age.  Unfortunately, there are a lot of employers out there that are discriminating against older people, especially women. A lot of temporary agencies are also guilty of this practice.  
  • Chastity Harrison
    Chastity Harrison
    To Kathleen: Your response should've been...IDK, I'm still undecided on my major! Secondly, you SHOULD enroll in a night class at a local college. You win! You've answered his question honestly(LOL!) and the class(es) can't hurt!!!!
  • Cheryl Crane
    Cheryl Crane
    Make sure your Facebook doesn't give out too  much free information about your family life.  If HR people are really looking at your on-line presence, they could pick up the very same "tell me about yourself" information from your Facebook and decide right then and there to skip calling for an interview. I am a highly qualified senior professional with 6 grandchildren, but that is none of the prospective employers business.
  • Michael McGahan
    Michael McGahan
    I'd like to pass along one other tip I got and have used.  After you have told the interviewer about yourself, you can very gently put the ball back in his court by asking, "Is there anything specific you would like to discuss?"  Or words to that effect.  In this manner, you are subtely shifting his focus back to your experience and background and away from your personal life.   
  • edner guintu
    edner guintu
    thank you the information.
  • Joseph Gonzalez
    Joseph Gonzalez
    Thank you writer of this article. I did not know I had the right to be evasive and protect my privacy and my family. Good to know. Three cheers for good people like you.
  • TR Wilmac
    TR Wilmac
    Great information. I've always been annoyed at this question because it leaves me feeling as if I wasted my time sending my resume.  Not only does my resume listed my education and work history but it also list organizations & community activities that I am involved with.  If a recuriter truly posses interviewing skills, the essence of who I am and the potential fit to their company should be obvious.  I would like to read your suggestion on how to get a foot in the employment door when one is just about 50 and have been out of the work force for 3 years to pursue and have obtained a BA.
  • Tyra Kora
    Tyra Kora
    You are so right, I worked for a large banking institution and those are illegal questions, we couldn't ask anyone opening an account any of those questions. So it can't be asked in an interview either.
  • chetraj sing Bagratee
    chetraj sing Bagratee
    Thank you very much. It's really a very good information to get the first foot ahead in an interwiew. I want to learn more...
  • Daniel Onyambu
    Daniel Onyambu
    I recently fell into this trap. I wish I had read this article before that interview. Now I know and thank you very much for this info.
  • James R.
    James R.
    The simple reality of the entire process is that most HR personnel are not qualified to make psychological judgment calls on anyone; let alone someone they have fewer than 15 minutes to "know".  We're all being analyzed by some mystic belief that they've been trained to find the best of the best, through their extensive "training". In fact, they have ZERO proof of their expertise, mainly because the best worker was probably overlooked simply because they didn't answer some trick question the "proper" way. You can't declare the chosen employee "the best", if you can't compare their actual work to the other candidates.  You've only chosen the best interviewee, not the best WORK candidate.The fact that each HR personnel has their own personal spin on the "proper" answer makes the entire process seemingly fruitless.  Add in the number of people in HR that are clearly not qualified (as noted in the above examples) and the process becomes absurd.Obviously, there's no perfect method to finding the best work candidate, but trick questions have become the norm; to the detriment of truly good workers and to all employers.  We've all been stuck picking up the slack from co-workers more intent on working the system than actually working; those are the people, that more often than not, excel at those trick questions.Still, it's helpful to know information like this; we're obligated to play the game even w/ limited knowledge of the rules.
  • CLARA BALAJADIA
    CLARA BALAJADIA
    This article is the best i've ever read. It gives me an idea of how I conduct myself  during a job interview. Thanks for the input.

Jobs to Watch